Been here recently? Are the menu details still right?
Prices and times change constantly. A quick check keeps this page honest for the next person.
Thanks, what's changed?
Pick anything that's off. We'll update the listing.
What's different
Prices are differentTimes or days changedItems have changedNo longer offeredSomething else
Your note may be published on this page to help other visitors. No name required.
Add a photo of the menu board (optional)
Want to know when it's fixed?
Thanks, that helps.
Marked as confirmed today. Every check keeps this menu honest for the next person.
Got it, thank you.
We'll verify against the restaurant and update this listing as soon as we can. If your note is helpful we'll publish it here so the next person knows too.
Two eggs cooked your way with choice of grilled Canadian bacon, sausage or bacon and your choice of toast (white, wheat, rye or sour dough). Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$14.99
Build your Omelet
3 fluffy eggs-just pick 3 toppings. Add more toppings for an additional charge. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$14.99
Captiva Scrambler
Eggs, ham, bell peppers, and sweet diced onions all scrambled together. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$14.99
Eggs on a Roll
Two scrambled eggs, grilled Canadian bacon and American cheese, served on a fresh baked roll. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$12.99
Captiva Breakfast Burrito
Stuffed with black beans, onions,bell peppers, sausage, eggs and cheese. Sour cream and homemade salsa on the side.. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$17.99
Eggs Benny
Two poached eggs over English muffins, Canadian bacon, topped with hollandaise sauce. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$14.99
Crabby Benny's
Two English muffins topped with our bestselling crab cakes cooked until golden brown, poached eggs and hollandaise sauce. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$23.99
Crabby Times
Our bestselling crab cakes topped with two scrambles eggs and savory melted cheddar and jack cheese. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$22.99
Island Pancakes
3 Fluffy pancakes (of your choice). Buttermilk, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip or Blueberry Granola. Powdered sugar sprinkled on top. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$12.99
Pigs in a Pancake
3 plump pork sausages stuffed inside our delicious, old fashioned buttermilk pancakes. Sprinkled with powdered sugar. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$14.99
French Toast
Homemade with our thick slices of Texas-style toast. Sprinkled with powdered sugar. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$13.99
Happy Otter
French toast layered with scrambled eggs and Canadian bacon
$15.99
Belgian Style Waffle
Freshly made and served with kiwi, strawberries and whipped cream.
$11.99
Granola N' Berries
Topped with fresh berries and a splash of milk.
$11.99
Tropical Fruit Plate
Seasonal fruit piled high.
$14.99
Ultimate Seafood Omelet
Overstuffed with fresh gulf shrimp, fish, portobello mushrooms, red onion, bell peppers, and melted asiago cheese. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$21.99
Avocado Toast
$13.99
Breakfast Sides (23)
Bacon
$3.99
Canadian Bacon
$2.50
Sausage
$4.99
1 Egg
$2.00
2 eggs
$4.00
3 eggs
$4.50
Sd 1 Buttermilk Pancake
$3.50
Sd 2 Buttermilk pancakes
$6.00
Sd 3 Buttermilk pancakes
$6.00
Sd 1 Chocolate chip pancake
$4.00
Sd 2 Chocolate chip pancakes
$8.00
Sd 3 Chocolate chip pancakes
$6.75
Sd 1 Blueberry pancake
$3.50
Sd 2 Blueberry pancakes
$7.00
Sd 3 Blueberry pancakes
$9.99
Sd1B.berry Granola pancake
$4.00
Sd 2 Blueberry granola pancakes
$5.50
Sd 3 Blueberry granola pancakes
$9.99
English Muffin
$3.00
Potatoes
$3.00
Toast
$2.00
Side French Toast
$4.99
Sliced Tomato
$2.00
Kids Breakfast (6)
Kid Scrambled Eggs N' Ham
Scrambled eggs and canadian bacon. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$9.99
Kid Scrambled Eggs
Two eggs scrambled. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$9.99
Kid French Toast
Homemade with our thick slices of Texas-style toast. Sprinkled with powdered sugar. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$9.99
Kid Pancakes
Two fluffy pancakes of your choosing. Sprinkled with powdered sugar. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$9.99
Kid Cheese Omelet
Two egg omelet topped with melted American cheese. Sided with fruit and potatoes.
$9.99
Kid Fruit Plate
Seasonal fresh fruit piled high.
$9.99
Appetizers (12)
Conch Fritters
Captiva Island style hush puppies stuffed with veggies and fresh local conch meat.
$16.99
Calamari
A Captiva specialty sided with fresh lemons and marinara dipping sauce.
$15.99
Fries
Seasoned French fries
$7.99
Crab Cake App
Two of our famous lump crab cakes served with our homemade tropical mago dip
$22.99
Pico De Gallo
Homemade salsa served with freshly made tortilla chips
$10.99
Smoked Mahi Fish Dip
A delicious Captiva Island fish dip prepared with mayo, celery, carrots, onions and a hint of red pepper, served chilled with crackers
$14.99
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
An old favorite. Served hot with freshly made tortilla chips on the side
$10.99
Corn Chips
$2.00
Bread
$2.50
Garlic Bread
$2.00
Potato Chips
$1.50
Sweet Potato Fries
$9.99
Soups and Salads (12)
Small Baby Greens
Crisp field greens and tomoatoes topped with fresh raspberry vinaigrette. Add a topping below to make it a meal
$7.99
Large Baby Greens
Crisp field greens and tomoatoes topped with fresh raspberry vinaigrette. Add a topping below to make it a meal
$9.99
Cup Black Beans and Rice
An islander favorite (and RC Otter's secret recipe)-topped with sweet diced onions, cheddar cheese, and a dollop of sour cream on the side
$7.99
Small Caesar
Our "World Famous" Caesar salad. Add your choice of hearty topping below to make it a meal
$7.99
Large Caesar
Our "World Famous" Caesar salad. Add your choice of hearty topping below to make it a meal
$9.99
Bowl Black Beans and Rice
An islander favorite (and RC Otter's secret recipe)-topped with sweet diced onions, cheddar cheese, and a dollop of sour cream on the side. Make it a meal with a topping below (bowl only)
$12.99
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Tender, fresh gulf shrimp piled on top of mixed greens, served with a citrus vinaigrette and seasonal melon and berries
$24.99
Blackened Tuna Salad
Fresh tuna steak with Cajun seasoning on top of mixed greens, served with a mango vinaigrette and seasonal melon and berries
$27.99
Soup Of Day
$4.99
Bowl Soup Of Day
$6.99
Lobster Bisque Cup
$7.99
Lobster Bisque Bowl
$11.99
Kids Dinner (7)
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Served with chips and a pickle
$9.99
Kid Burger
Ground beef patty, served with chips and a pickle
$9.99
Kid Chicken Fingers
3 strips with chips and a pickle and your choice of ranch, bbq or honey mustard
$9.99
Kid Quesa
Fresh grilled tortilla with cheddar cheese
$9.99
Mac N' Cheese
Served with chips and a pickle
$9.99
Cheese Dog
1/4 lb hot dog topped with American cheese and served with chips and a pickle
$9.99
Kid Spaghetti
Served with marinara sauce or butter, topped with fresh grated parmesan cheese
$9.99
Raw and Steamed (12)
Peel N' Eat Shrimp 1/2 lb
$16.99
Peel N' Eat Shrimp 1 lb
$30.99
Oysters 6 Raw
Fresh Gulf Oysters shucked to order
$17.99
Oysters 12 Raw
Fresh Gulf Oysters shucked to order
$30.99
Steamed Shrimp Pot
One dozen guld shrimp, peel and eat style. in a broth with veggies and potatoes
$32.99
Steamed Clam Pot
One dozen fresh clams in their own juice, a heaping pot full in a broth with veggies and pototoes
$30.99
Steamed Shrimp/Clam pot
Shrimp and clams together in our homemade broth with veggies and potatoes
$32.99
1\2 Med Stone
$26.00
1 Lb Med Stone
$47.00
1\2 Large Stone
$29.00
1 Lb Large Stone
$55.00
1 Lb Jumbo
$75.00
Sandwiches (11)
Catch of the day sandwich
Your choice of fresh catch prepared grilled, blackened or bronzed on a fresh roll
$26.99
Crunchy Fish Sandwich
Island catch, lightly fried to a crispy golden brown served on a fresh roll
$23.99
Crunchy Fish Reuben
Our island crunchy fish nestled in Swiss cheese, coleslaw and 1000 island dressing on rye bread
$23.99
"Uncle Hanks" Grilled Fish Reuben
Grilled fish with Swiss cheese, coleslaw and 1000 island dressing on rye bread
$23.99
Crab Cake Burger
Crisp and golden brown on a fresh roll
$23.99
Crunchy Fish Tacos
Two soft shell tacos filled with our crunchy fish and served with a cup of beans and rice.
$24.99
Cheeseburger in Paradise
Half pound fresh ground beef with your choice of American, cheddar jack, Swiss or blue cheese
$17.99
Captiva Cuban Sandwich
Cuban style pressed-roasted seasoned pork, ham and swiss cheese topped with pickle and dressing on crispy Cuban bread. Served with black beans and rice
$18.99
Captiva Chicken Sandwich
Char-grilled chicken breast topped with fresh guacamole, homemade salsa and melted swiss cheese on a fresh roll
$17.99
Classic French Dip
Drenched, mouthwatering roast beef with grilled onions, Swiss cheese and delicious Aus Jus
$17.99
Grouper sandwich
$30.99
Basket (7)
Crunchy Fish Basket
Island catch, lightly fried to a crispy golden brown
$23.99
Fried Shrimp Basket
6 plump gulf shrimp fried to a crispy golden brown
$22.99
Chicken Finger Basket
Tender, plump chicken breast lightly fried with our special recipe, served with BBQ sauce, ranch or honey mustard
$19.99
Fried Calamari Basket
Tender, hand breaded calamari lightlly fried to perfection
$17.99
Fried Grouper Basket
$27.99
Coconut Shrimp Basket
$24.99
Grouper Fingers
$32.99
Dinners (13)
12oz Florida Lobster Tail
Firm fresh Florida lobster tail served with drawn butter sauce for dipping
$38.99
Any Fish you wish
Fresh catch of the day, just the way you like it! Grilled, bronzed or blackened
$36.99
Baby Back Ribs
This full rack of Danish Ribs are considered by many to be the world's greatest
$36.99
Coconut Shrimp Platter
Seven shrimp lightly battered and butterflied, served with plum sauce
$32.99
Crab Cake Platter
Three of our famous lump crab cakes served with a side or tropical mango dipping sauce
$38.99
Crunchy Fish Platter
This lightly battered secret RC Otter's fish recipe will bring you back again and again
$29.99
Grouper Oscar
Grilled fresh grouper topped with blue crabmeat, fresh asparagus spears and finished with hollandaise sauce
$42.99
Filet mignon
A tender 12oz choice, center-cut New York Strip chargrilled to your liking
$48.99
Salmon Oscar
Grilled fresh salmon topped with blue crabmeat, fresh asparagus spears and finished with hollandaise sauce
$38.99
Seafood Combo Platter
Your choice of fresh fish, served with two gulf shrimp and two scallops, prepared your way of grilled, blackened or bronzed
$50.99
Shrimp Platter
Seven gulf shrimp, prepared your way- grilled, bronzed, blackened or fried
$29.99
You Catch We Cook
$20.00
Crab Cake 2
$32.99
Fajitas/Quesadillas (17)
Veggie Fajitas
Fresh broccoli, zucchini, squash, bell peppers, asparagus, Portobello mushrooms, cauliflower and onions in a cast iron skillet with all the toppings
$21.99
Chx/Stk Fajitas
Marinated chicken and steak, savory peppers and sweet onions in a cast iron skillet with all the toppings
$32.99
Seafood Fajitas
Sizzling cast iron skillet full of fresh fish, shrimp, scallops, sweet onions and bell peppers served with all the toppings
$34.99
Shrimp Fajitas
$33.99
Tortilla
$0.50
Veggie Quesadilla
Crisp flour tortilla bursting with fresh veggies and smothered with cheddar jack chesse
$17.99
Steak N' Cheese Quesadilla
Crisp flour tortilla stuffed with marinated steak, peppers, onions and cheddar cheese
$21.99
Teriyaki Chicken N' Cheese Quesadilla
Crisp flour tortilla stuffed with chicken, peppers, onions, cheddar jack cheese and finished with sweet teriyaki sauce
$20.99
Salsa
$0.50
Sm Sd Pico
$1.99
Lg Sd Pico
$3.99
Steak Fajitas
$29.99
Bean Quesadilla
$9.00
2oz Guacamole
$0.75
4oz Guacamole
$1.50
Xt Jalapenos
$0.50
Chicken Fajitas
$28.99
Pasta (2)
Linguini Marinara
Perfectly cooked pasta served with marinara and topped with fresh grated parmesan cheese
$16.99
Shrimp or Clam Linguini
Fresh guld shrimp or fresh clams, herbs, garlic and tomato over linguini, topped with marinara sauce and fresh grated parmesan cheese
$26.99
Dessert (14)
Key Lime Pie
Made fresh in house traditional keylime pie
$9.99
Chocolate Cake
Triple layer chocolate cake
$9.99
limoncello
With cream cheese frosting
$8.99
Fudge Brownie
A heaping scoop of vanilla ice cream on top of a homemade brownie with your choice of hot fudge, caramel or strawberry sauce
$10.99
Hot Fudge Sundae
$8.99
Caramel Sundae
$8.99
Strawberrry Sundae
$8.99
Strawberry Cheesecake
NY style topped with strawberry sauce
$9.99
Caramel Brownie
$10.99
A La Mode
$4.00
Whole Key Lime Pie
$38.00
Strawberry Brownie
$9.99
Ricotta pistachio pie
$9.99
jamaica Rum Cake
$10.99
Dinner sides (27)
Side Fries
$4.99
Mashed Potatoes
$4.99
Rice
$4.99
Coleslaw
$4.99
Mixed Veggies
$4.99
Broccoli
$4.99
Corn
$4.99
Asparagus
$4.99
Fish
$17.99
Chicken
$8.99
Steak
$14.99
Portobello/Peppers
$7.99
1 Shrimp
$3.75
2 Shrimp
$7.50
3 Shrimp
$11.25
4 Shrimp
$15.00
Sweet Fries
$4.99
2 Scallop
$7.50
3 Scallop
$11.25
4 Scallop
$15.00
Reg Mushrooms
$3.00
Mash And Gravy
$2.00
Ranch
$0.25
BBQ
$0.25
Honey Mustard
$0.25
Sweet potato fries
$4.99
coconut shrimp
$21.99
Special (7)
chicken Alfredo
$27.99
breakfast
$500.00
Stuffed Grouper
$60.00
SURF AND TURF
$80.00
catering
$650.00
Shrimp Alfredo
$29.99
Brisket
$28.99
Sizzle Dining Dinner (5)
Tequila sunrise
$9.00
Veggie Fajitas
Fresh broccoli, zucchini, squash, bell peppers, asparagus, Portobello mushrooms, cauliflower and onions in a cast iron skillet with all the toppings
Shrimp or Clam Linguini
Fresh guld shrimp or fresh clams, herbs, garlic and tomato over linguini, topped with marinara sauce and fresh grated parmesan cheese
Fudge Brownie
A heaping scoop of vanilla ice cream on top of a homemade brownie with your choice of hot fudge, caramel or strawberry sauce
Small Baby Greens
Crisp field greens and tomoatoes topped with fresh raspberry vinaigrette. Add a topping below to make it a meal
Sizzle Dinning Lunch 29.00 (4)
Sizzle Dining
$29.00
Pico De Gallo
Homemade salsa served with freshly made tortilla chips
Bowl Black Beans and Rice
An islander favorite (and RC Otter's secret recipe)-topped with sweet diced onions, cheddar cheese, and a dollop of sour cream on the side. Make it a meal with a topping below (bowl only)
Veggie Fajitas
Fresh broccoli, zucchini, squash, bell peppers, asparagus, Portobello mushrooms, cauliflower and onions in a cast iron skillet with all the toppings
ALCOHOL
Flights/Tasters
Flight 9
$9.00
Flight 10
$10.00
Flight 12
$12.00
Flight 14
$14.00
Flight 16
$16.00
Taster 3
$3.00
Taster 4
$4.00
Taster 5
$5.00
Taster 6
$6.00
Taster 7
$7.00
Specialty 8 oz
$13.00
Fish Charity
Fish Charity
$10.00
Full Menu
Own this restaurant? Claim it
Own RC Otter's Island Eats? Claim this listing to add your full menu, prices and hours.
