Yoder's Restaurant Menu With Prices

Name: Yoder's Restaurant
Address: 3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239, Sarasota, FL, US
Telephone: (941) 955-7771
Price range: $

Contact & Location

restaurant · $

3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239

(941) 955-7771 · tap to call

yodersrestaurant.com

How far is Yoder's Restaurant?

3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239

Distance from central Sarasota1.1 mi

Straight-line distance from the midpoint of our Sarasota listings.

Get Directions

Hours of Operation

Monday7 AM–8 PM

Tuesday7 AM–8 PM

Wednesday7 AM–8 PM

Thursday7 AM–8 PM

Friday7 AM–8 PM

Saturday7 AM–8 PM

SundayClosed

See It Before You Go

Short videos of Yoder's Restaurant from people who went: restaurant, amish style restaurant, visit, review, homestyle cooking, dinner rolls. Tap to play.

Videos by @ex_amish_milo · Meghan Mayer · @housematchfl · @foodiejustice, playing in the creator’s official Facebook / TikTok players.Not affiliated with DiscoverHappyHours.

Happy Hour & Drinks

Updated August 2026

Yoder's Restaurant does not currently offer a confirmed happy hour. The restaurant features full food and drink menus with prices across 166 verified items, available in full detail below.

Daily Specials

Monday

Specials include choice of two side dishes (small order with one side)

Smoked BBQ Chicken*

Slow roasted, juicy and tender. Served with garlic toast.

$18.95/$16.95

Beef & Noodles

$12.95/$15.95

Pulled Smoked Pork

Smoked for hours, pulled off the bone in tender pieces. Outrageously delicious!

$14.95/$17.95

Tuesday

Chicken Pot Pie

Served with one side.

$16.95

BBQ Pulled Pork over Mac N Cheese

Served with one side.

$17.95

Wednesday

Goulash

Ground beef and macaroni in a zesty tomato sauce. Yummy!

$12.95/$15.95

Pot Roast & Vegetables

Slowly braised with carrots, celery, onion and potatoes. Served with one side.

$21.95

Thursday

Smoked BBQ Chicken*

Slow roasted, juicy and tender. Served with garlic bread.

$18.95/$16.95

Chicken Livers

Lightly breaded, seasoned and pan fried. Served with stuffing.

$12.95/$15.95

Friday

Cabbage Rolls

Ground beef, sausage, rice and seasonings rolled in cabbage leaves with a light tomato sauce.

$12.95/$15.95

Spaghetti

Served with one side.

$19.95

Saturday

Chicken Livers & Stuffing

Livers are lightly breaded, seasoned and pan fried. Served with our stuffing

$12.95/$15.95

Smoked BBQ Chicken

Slow roasted, juicy and tender. Served with garlic toast.

$18.95/$16.95

Been here recently? Are the menu details still right?

Prices and times change constantly. A quick check keeps this page honest for the next person.

Thanks, what's changed?

Pick anything that's off. We'll update the listing.

What's different

Prices are differentTimes or days changedItems have changedNo longer offeredSomething else

Your note may be published on this page to help other visitors. No name required.

Add a photo of the menu board (optional)

Want to know when it's fixed?

Thanks, that helps.

Marked as confirmed today. Every check keeps this menu honest for the next person.

Got it, thank you.

We'll verify against the restaurant and update this listing as soon as we can. If your note is helpful we'll publish it here so the next person knows too.

Updated August 2026

Yoder's Restaurant Breakfast Menu

Traditional Breakfast

Two Farm Fresh Eggs

With home fries or grits and hearty multigrain toast. With bacon or sausage.

$9.95/$12.95

Country Breakfast

Country fried steak smothered in a pepper gravy, with two eggs, home fries and a southern biscuit.

$14.95

Combo Breakfast

Two eggs and bacon with your choice of two mini pancakes or one piece of French toast.

$12.95

Cheesy Grits & Two Eggs

Two eggs your way, served on top creamy Gouda grits.

$10.95

Corn Meal Mush

Three pieces with butter and warm syrup. Smothered with sausage gravy.

$7.95/$10.50

Mom’s Homemade Sweet Roll

Served warm. A customer favorite!

$6.95

Amish Skillet

Choose your favorite skillet below mixed with home fries, topped with melted cheese and two farm fresh eggs and a southern biscuit.

$15.95

Ham and mushroom

Fresh chopped veggies

Sausage and onion

Fresh and Healthy

Cranberry Nut Oatmeal

Slow cooked organic rolled oats topped with cranberries, chopped Georgia pecans, brown sugar, low fat milk and a fruit muffin.

$7.95

Oatmeal with Brown Sugar

As simple as that.

$6.95

High Protein and Gluten Free

Three large eggs scrambled with melted cheese, turkey sausage and tomato slices.

$10.95

Fresh Fruit Bowl

$8.95

Sausage and Gravy

Biscuits and Sausage Gravy

$11.95

Home Fries and Sausage Gravy

$11.95

Cup of Sausage Gravy

$5.50

Benedicts

Country Benedict

Grilled southern biscuit topped with sausage patties, two soft basted farm fresh eggs and sausage gravy, served with home fries.

$15.95

Traditional Benedict

Toasted English muffin topped with thin sliced country ham, two soft basted eggs and hollandaise sauce, served with home fries.

$13.95

Omelettes

Made with three extra large farm fresh eggs with home fries and hearty multigrain toast

Cheese Omelette

$10.95

Sausage, Onion and Colby Jack Cheese

$12.95

Fresh Veggies and Cheese

$11.95

Bacon, Mushroom and Cheddar Cheese

$12.95

Fresh Spinach, Mushroom and Swiss Cheese

$11.95

Western

Ham, onions, bell peppers, mushrooms and Colby Jack cheese. Served with a side of salsa

$12.95

Breakfast Sandwich

Classic Fried Egg on Toast

$6.95

Egg, Bacon and Cheese Biscuit

$8.95

Egg and Cheese on Croissant

$8.50

Pancakes

Yoder’s Original or Made from Scratch Whole Wheat

$6.95/$8.50

Specialty Pancakes - Choose Your Favorite

Topped with Cinnamon Apples, Blueberry, Pecan, Chocolate Chip, Sweet Roll Swirl, Peanut Butter Pie

$9.50/$10.50

Homemade French Toast

Traditional French Toast

Thick sliced homemade bread, grilled golden brown and served with butter and warm syrup.

$6.95/$8.95

Raspberry Stuffed French Toast

Thick sliced bread, grilled golden brown, stuffed with cream cheese and raspberry filling.

$8.95/$10.95

Sides & Extras

Mom’s Homemade Sweet Roll

$6.95

Home Fries, Grits or Fresh Fruit

$4.95

Baked Hot Cinnamon Apples

$4.95

Sausage, Bacon or Ham

$5.50

Two Mini Pancakes

$5.50

Toast: Hearty Multigrain, White, Cracked Wheat or Rye

$3.95

Southern Biscuit

$3.95

Homemade Fruit Bread

$3.95

Assorted Muffins

$4.50

Extra Egg with Order

$1.95

Substitute Egg Whites

Add 1.00 per egg

Yoder's Restaurant Lunch and Dinner Menu

Salads & More

Dressings: Kraft Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette

Cobb Salad

Chopped turkey, egg, peas, bacon, cheese and tomatoes. Layered on a bed of crisp lettuce. Our customers’ favorite!

$17.95

Breaded or Grilled Chicken Salad

Breaded chicken tenders or grilled chicken breast, served on top of crisp lettuce. Garnished with cucumber, cheese, tomato and egg.

$18.95

Taco Salad

A bed of crisp lettuce with onions, cheese and tomatoes. Served with Mom’s Homemade Chili over the top and tortilla chips.

$16.95

Vegetable Plate

Choice of three side dishes and homemade bread. Add a fourth side for 4.00

$12.95

Side Salad

Farm fresh field greens topped with tomato, onion, cucumber, shredded cheese, and croutons.

$6.95

Wavy Gravy

French Fries covered with beef gravy & melted cheddar.

$8.95

Onion Rings

Thick cut onion rings, battered and deep fried till golden crisp. Served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$7.95

Corn Bread Muffins & Dinner Roll Basket

A sharable basket filled with our homemade dinner rolls and corn bread. Served with apple butter. (Serves 5).

$6.95

Soups

Homemade Soup of the Day

Ask your server

$5.95/$6.95

Mom’s Homemade Chili

$5.95/$6.95

Cup of Soup with Half Chicken Salad Sandwich

$9.95

Yoder’s Famous Fried Chicken

Country cooking Southern style. All-natural chicken, hand breaded and deep pressure fried to seal in the juices and give it a crispy texture outside. Customers’ favorite, hands down! Our House Dressing makes the perfect dipping sauce!

Half Chicken (4 pc.)

$22.95/$19.95/$23.95

Quarter Chicken (2 pc.)

$16.95/$18.95

Chicken and Turkey

Garlic Chicken Breast

8 oz. skinless, boneless all-natural breast marinated in our special garlic recipe and sautéed. Plain breast also available.

$16.95

Chicken Fingers

Tender strips of chicken breaded and deep fried. Comes with BBQ sauce for dipping or your choice of dressing.

$15.95/$18.95

Roasted Turkey Breast & Stuffing

White meat turkey breast and homemade stuffing smothered in our made-from-stock beef gravy.

$16.95/$19.95

Baked Chicken & Stuffing

Bone in chicken lightly dusted in our homemade seasoning, baked until juicy and delicious. Served with stuffing and your choice of two sides.

$16.95/$18.95

Traditional Trio

All the favorites: meatloaf, turkey and fried chicken! Served with homemade mashed potatoes and green beans.

$21.95

Seafood

Shrimp & Cheesy Grits

Southern goodness. Blackened grilled shrimp served on homemade cheesy grits with one side.

$19.95

Shrimp

Your choice of breaded butterflied shrimp or grilled seasoned shrimp. Served with cocktail sauce and two sides.

$19.95

Fish N Chips with Slaw

Fish fried crispy and delicious, served with fries.

$19.95

Sandwiches

Southern Fried Chicken B.L.T

Crispy fried chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, dijonnaise, fresh lettuce and tomato on a brioche roll.

$16.95

Grilled Chicken Breast

All-natural: garlic seasoned or plain.

$14.95

Grilled Cheese

Choose from American, Swiss, Cheddar or Colby

$8.95

Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato

$9.95

Fried Fish Sandwich

Add Cheese 2.00

$10.95

BBQ Pork Sandwich

$10.95

Chicken Salad

$9.95

Pot Roast Melt

Topped with sautéed onions and melted provolone on a sub roll. Served with Au jus.

$16.95

Crispy Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich

Golden-fried chicken tenders, slaw and tangy pickles, drizzled with hot honey. Sweet-heat perfection.

$14.95

Manhattans

On homemade bread, served with real mashed potatoes, and smothered in our made-from-stock beef gravy

Roast Beef, Turkey or Meatloaf

$13.95/$16.95

Beef and Pork

Smoked Ham

Sliced thick and grilled. Our Amish guests say it’s the best!

$14.95/$16.95

Roast Beef

Well done and served Amish chunky style. Smothered in our made-from-stock beef gravy.

$16.95/$19.95

Liver & Onions

Grilled tender and topped with cooked onions. With bacon add 3.95

$16.95

Shepherd’s Pie

Ground beef and veggies topped with mashed potatoes & cheese. Includes choice of one side.

$16.95

Mom’s Meatloaf

A country-style favorite! Perfectly seasoned and smothered in our made-from-stock beef gravy.

$15.95/$17.95

Country Fried Steak

Golden fried chopped beef steak, smothered in a rich pepper country gravy.

$17.95

Build Your Own Burger

1/3 Pound Fresh Ground Beef Burger Served on a Brioche bun. Top with your favorites: Lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, mayo

$9.95

Cheese (American, Swiss, Cheddar, Colby)

$2.00

Crispy Bacon

$3.00

Grilled Onions

$2.00

Grilled Mushrooms

$2.00

Add a side dish to your burger for only 4.00

$4.00

Sorry, no discount on one less side dish with dinners

Side Dishes Á la Carte

Mashed Potatoes with Gravy

$4.95

Chicken Stuffing

$4.95

Cheesy Grits

$4.95

French Fries

$4.95

Mac N Cheese

$4.95

Fried Okra

$4.95

Corn Bread Muffins

$4.95

Buttered Corn

$4.95

Amish Noodles

$4.95

Green Beans

$4.95

Vegetable Medley

$4.95

Hot Baked Apples

$4.95

Cole Slaw

$4.95

Baked Potato (after 4pm)

$4.95

Baked Sweet Potato (after 4pm)

$4.95

Side Salad

Add $2

$4.95

Yoder's Restaurant Dessert Menu

Homemade Pies

Our pies are baked fresh FROM SCRATCH every morning No meal at Yoder’s is ever complete without a piece of homemade pie

$7.95

À la mode

$2.00

Cream Pies

Banana Cream

Chocolate Cream

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Coconut Cream

Florida Key Lime(Traditional in graham crust)

Fresh Strawberry

Homemade Butterscotch

Peanut Butter Cream

Baked Pies

Apple

Blueberry

Cherry

Dutch Apple Crumb

Pumpkin

Southern Pecan

Blackberry

Black Raspberry

Baked Peach

Rhubarb

Strawberry Rhubarb

Mom’s Egg Custard

Shoofly

Sugar-free Apple

Cakes and More

Homemade Cheesecake

$7.95

Yoder’s Best Chocolate Cake

$7.50

Cake of the Day

$7.50

Hand-dipped Ice Cream

$4.95

Hand-dipped Ice Cream

with Fresh Strawberries

$6.95

Pie Flight - Sample your choice of three cream pie flavors

$10.50

Take Home Pie

10” Whole Pie

(Serves 6-10)

$28.95

8” Whole Cream Pie

(Serves 4-6)

$20.95

Whole Cake Variety of Choices

(Serves 4-6)

$15.95

Whole Cheesecake

(Serves 10-14)

$34.95

Mom’s Homemade Sweet Rolls (1)

$6.95

Mom’s Homemade Sweet Rolls (4)

$15.95

Loaf of White or Wheat Bread

$3.95

Homemade Apple Butter (Pint)

$7.95

Homemade House Dressing (Pint)

$7.95

Full Menu

Own this restaurant? Claim it

Own Yoder's Restaurant? Claim this listing to add your full menu, prices and hours.

Claim this listing

Photos & Gallery

Own this restaurant? Claim it

Own Yoder's Restaurant? Claim this listing to add photos of your space.

Claim this listing

Frequently Asked Questions

What food does Yoder's Restaurant serve?

Yoder's Restaurant publishes Lunch and Dinner Menu, Breakfast Menu, Daily Specials, 125 dishes. Dishes start at 1.95.

Does Yoder's Restaurant have dessert?

Yes, 41 on the menu. Homemade Pies 7.95, À la mode 2.00, Homemade Cheesecake 7.95.

Where is Yoder's Restaurant located?

Yoder's Restaurant is located at 3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239.

Is Yoder's Restaurant good for groups?

Yoder's Restaurant is a restaurant in Sarasota. For large groups, we recommend calling ahead at (941) 955-7771 to check availability.

What type of restaurant is Yoder's Restaurant?

Yoder's Restaurant is a restaurant located in Sarasota, FL.

FAQ

Own this restaurant? Claim it

Own Yoder's Restaurant? Claim it to answer diners' questions right on this page.

Claim this listing

Other Happy Hours in Sarasota

View all happy hours in Sarasota →

Is this your business?

Claim your free listing to update your hours, specials, photos, and more.

Claim Your Free Listing

Print On Demand Custom Apparel

Get Your Free Merch Storefront

Join thousands selling custom apparel the easy way. Pick from premium blanks, add your art, and let us handle the rest. Free to get started.

Create Free Shop →

Yoder's Restaurant

Contact & Location

How far is Yoder's Restaurant?

Hours of Operation

See It Before You Go

Happy Hour & Drinks

Yoder's Restaurant Happy Hour

Yoder's Restaurant Specials Menu

Thanks, that helps.

Got it, thank you.

Yoder's Restaurant Breakfast Menu

Yoder's Restaurant Lunch and Dinner Menu

Yoder's Restaurant Dessert Menu

Full Menu

Photos & Gallery

Frequently Asked Questions

FAQ

Other Happy Hours in Sarasota

Is this your business?

Get Your Free Merch Storefront