My New Joint Menu With Prices

Contact & Location

oyster bar restaurant · $

22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042

(305) 745-8880 · tap to call

mynewjoint420lounge.com

How far is My New Joint?

22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042

Distance from central Cudjoe Keyin the centre

Straight-line distance from the midpoint of our Cudjoe Key listings.

Get Directions

Hours of Operation

MondayClosed

Tuesday4:20–11 PM

Wednesday4:20–11 PM

Thursday4:20–11 PM

Friday4:20–11 PM

Saturday4:20–11 PM

SundayClosed

Happy Hour & Drinks

Updated August 2026

My New Joint does not currently offer a confirmed happy hour. The bar features full food and drink menus with prices across 88 verified items, available in full detail below.

MARTINIS

Cafe Con Leche

Tito's Vodka, Kahlua, white chocolate liqueur, fresh espresso

$14

Key Lime Martini

Smirnoff Vanilla Vodka, key lime curd, fresh lime, simple syrup, graham cracker rim

$15

Millionaire Manhattan

WhistlePig PiggyBack Bourbon - OR - Rye, Sweet Vermouth, brown sugar simple syrup, spicy bitters, candied bacon

$15

Lavender Haze

Empress Gin, Solerno Blood Orange, lavender bitters, fresh lemon, simple syrup

$14

99 Problems

Captain Morgan Spiced Rum, 99 Coconut liqueur, Midori, pineapple, fresh lime, simple syrup

$14

Strawberry Grouper

Tito's Vodka, muddled strawberry, fresh lime, basil, ginger, simple syrup

$14

Grouper Breeze

Mutiny Vodka, muddled strawberry, lychee liqueur, cranberry, pineapple

$13

Indica

Rosemary infused Tito's Vodka, fresh lime, grapefruit

$12

Reefer Madness

Bombora Vodka, blue curaçao, fresh lime, pineapple, ginger beer

$12

Toasted Coconut Mojito

Rumhaven Coconut Rum, coconut milk, mint, fresh lime, toasted coconut flakes

$13

Bud Head

Ron Zacapa Rum, Campari, muddled orange, pineapple, fresh lime, simple syrup

$13

Flower Power

Hendricks Flora Adora Gin, raspberry puree, fresh lime, hibiscus syrup, ginger beer

$13

Spicy Paloma

Milagro Tequila, chili liqueur, grapefruit, fresh lime, club soda

$12

Bubonic Chronic

Tanteo Jalapeno Tequila, triple sec, cilantro, fresh lime, simple syrup

$13

Mary's Margarita

Tanteo Chipotle Tequila, Chinola liqueur, passion fruit puree, fresh lime, simple syrup

$13

Smoke 'N' Toke

Pinhook Bourbon - OR - Rye, sugar, bitters, smoked in glass

$13

Key West Old Fashioned

Pilar Dark Rum, local honey, cherry juice, lime bitters

$14

Gin Drank

Fords Gin, triple sec, local honey, basil, fresh lemon + lime

$12

Gold Rush

Bulleit Bourbon, local honey, fresh lemon

$13

Blueberry Yum Yum

Stoli Blueberi, blueberry liqueur, pomegranate, lavender bitters, prosecco

$12

Fresh Swig

Cumbé Aguardiente, white chocolate liqueur, fresh lemon, mint, simple syrup, prosecco

$12

Raspberry Express

Smirnoff Vanilla Vodka, Chambord, fresh lime, simple syrup, prosecco

$12

Hot Box

Effen Cucumber Vodka, muddled jalapeno, grapefruit, fresh lime, ginger beer

$12

Hibiscus Mule

Stoli Vodka, hibiscus syrup, fresh lime, ginger beer

$12

OG Mule

Stoli Vodka, fresh lime, simple syrup, ginger beer

$12

Reds by the Bottle

CABERNET SAUVIGNON

Honig ( CA )

$40/$80

CABERNET SAUVIGNON

Mount Veeder ( CA )

$70

MERLOT

Duckhorn ( CA ) / Half - 60

$60

PINOT NOIR

Boen ( CA )

$48

PINOT NOIR

Chehalem ( OR ) / Half - 30

$30

RED BLEND

Hands of Time ( CA )

$60

Reds by the Glass

CABERNET SAUVIGNON

Washington Hills (WA)

$10

MALBEC

Crios ( ARG )

$10

MERLOT

Tilia (ARG)

$10

PINOT NOIR

Deloach ( CA )

$10

RED BLEND

Z. Alexander Brown ( CA )

$10

TEMPRANILLO

Flaco ( ESP )

$10

ZINFANDEL

Artezin ( CA )

$10

Whites by the Bottle

SPARKLING

Chandon Brut ( CA ) / Split - 16

$16

ROSÉ

Miraval ( FRA ) / half - 25

$25

CHARDONNAY

Sonoma Cutrer ( CA )

$60

CHARDONNAY

Rombauer ( CA )

$80

CHAMPAGNE

Veuve Clicquot ( FRA )

$90

SAUVIGNON BLANC

Honig ( CA )

$48

Whites by the Glass

ALBARIÑO

Paco & Lola ( ESP )

$10

CHARDONNAY

Drumhelller ( WA )

$10

PINOT GRIGIO

San Giorgio ( ITA )

$10

PROSECCO

Mionetto ( ITA )

$10

RIESLING

Heinz Eifel ( DEU )

$10

ROSÉ

Henri Gaillard ( FRA )

$10

SAUVIGNON BLANC

Faultline ( NZL )

$10

SPARKLING

Steorra Brut ( CA )

$10

Been here recently? Are the menu details still right?

Prices and times change constantly. A quick check keeps this page honest for the next person.

Thanks, what's changed?

Pick anything that's off. We'll update the listing.

What's different

Prices are differentTimes or days changedItems have changedNo longer offeredSomething else

Your note may be published on this page to help other visitors. No name required.

Add a photo of the menu board (optional)

Want to know when it's fixed?

Thanks, that helps.

Marked as confirmed today. Every check keeps this menu honest for the next person.

Got it, thank you.

We'll verify against the restaurant and update this listing as soon as we can. If your note is helpful we'll publish it here so the next person knows too.

Updated August 2026

My New Joint Menu

Let’s Eat

Baked Artichoke & Spinach Dip

corn tortillas

$14

Portabella Fries

toasted fennel aioli | zesty ranch dip

$12

Ginormous Soft Pretzel

jalapeno cheese dip | lusty monk mustard

$16

Mac & Cheese

toasted breadcrumbs

Thai Chicken Lollipop Wings

$18

Buffalo Chicken Lollipop Wings

Blue Cheese

$18

Everchanging Empanadas

See today’s preparation on specials sheet

Voodoo Shrimp

creamy cajun sauce

$18

Roasted Cauliflower

green curry sauce

$14

Charred Brussels Sprouts

lemon & butter

$14

Cauliflower Au Gratin

roasted cauliflower & cheeses

$15

Roasted Beets

goat cheese | balsamic drizzle

$15

House Smoked Fish Dip

jalapeno | red onion | tomato

$18

Raw Bar

Peel & Eat Shrimp

house made cocktail sauce- half lb. 16. / full lb. 28

$16/$28

Fresh Shucked Oysters -> cucumber jalapeño mignonette - MP

-> today’s selection on specials sheet

Sandwiches

Served w/ shoestring fries | pickle

add salad or tots +2

Sauteéd Local Fish

key lime tartar | spicy slaw

Philly Cheesesteak

sauteéed onions & peppers | white cheddar

$17

Mary Jane’s Blaze Burger

jalapeno cheese sauce | bacon jam

$19

Sliders

Served w/ shoestring fries | pickle

add salad or tots +2

Filet Mignon Sliders

fried onions | horseradish sauce

$25

Fried Buffalo Chicken

onion | lettuce | house made buffalo sauce

$16

Greens & More

Communal Salad Bowl

Garden greens & fresh veggies - feta | quinoa. Dressing: herbed ranch, basil vinaigrette, blue cheese or maple dijon vinaigrette

$14/$19

Burrata Caprese

$20

Fried Root Vegetables

Shoe String Fries

parmesan | herbs | zesty ranch dip

$10

Crispy Tater Tots

buffalo sauce

$12

Loaded Tater Tots

jalapeno cheese | bacon | scallions

$14

Grilled Fresh Oysters

Half Dozen: garlic parmesan - 3. OR rockefeller - 4

$3/$4

Seafood Gumbo

Cup of Seafood Gumbo

$14

Bowl of Seafood Gumbo

$20

Everchanging Pasta Special

today’s preparation on specials sheet | choice of protein - 3 Local Fish +9. / 3 Chicken +7 / 3 Shrimp +8

Desserts

Magic Bar Sundae

$12

Key Lime Pie

bubba award winning | house specialty

Fried Banana Split

rice paper wrapped | salted caramel crunch ice cream | cinnamon sugar | praline pecans

$12

Full Menu

Own this bar? Claim it

Own My New Joint? Claim this listing to add your full menu, prices and hours.

Claim this listing

Photos & Gallery

Own this bar? Claim it

Own My New Joint? Claim this listing to add photos of your space.

Claim this listing

Frequently Asked Questions

Does My New Joint have a cocktail or drinks menu?

Yes. My New Joint lists 54 drinks on this page under Cocktail Menu, My New Joint Menu. Cafe Con Leche 14, Key Lime Martini 15, Millionaire Manhattan 15.

What food does My New Joint serve?

My New Joint publishes My New Joint Menu, 31 dishes. Dishes start at 9.

Does My New Joint have dessert?

Yes, 3 on the menu. Magic Bar Sundae 12, Key Lime Pie 9, Fried Banana Split 12.

Where is My New Joint located?

My New Joint is located at 22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042.

Is My New Joint good for groups?

My New Joint is an oyster bar restaurant in Cudjoe Key. For large groups, we recommend calling ahead at (305) 745-8880 to check availability.

What type of restaurant is My New Joint?

My New Joint is an oyster bar restaurant located in Cudjoe Key, FL.