Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies Menu With Prices

Name: Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies
Address: 850 N Jefferson St Unit 910, Monticello, FL 32344, Monticello, FL, US
Telephone: +1 850-997-4000
Price range: $

Contact & Location

pizza restaurant · $

850 N Jefferson St Unit 910, Monticello, FL 32344

+1 850-997-4000 · tap to call

bestpizza.place

How far is Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies?

850 N Jefferson St Unit 910, Monticello, FL 32344

Distance from central Monticelloin the centre

Straight-line distance from the midpoint of our Monticello listings.

Get Directions

Hours of Operation

Monday11 am–8:30 pm

TuesdayClosed

WednesdayClosed

Thursday11 am–8:30 pm

Friday11 am–8:30 pm

Saturday11 am–8:30 pm

Sunday11 am–8:30 pm

Happy Hour

Updated August 2026

Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies does not currently offer a confirmed happy hour. The restaurant features a food menu with prices across 126 verified items, available in full detail below.

Been here recently? Are the menu details still right?

Prices and times change constantly. A quick check keeps this page honest for the next person.

Thanks, what's changed?

Pick anything that's off. We'll update the listing.

What's different

Prices are differentTimes or days changedItems have changedNo longer offeredSomething else

Your note may be published on this page to help other visitors. No name required.

Add a photo of the menu board (optional)

Want to know when it's fixed?

Thanks, that helps.

Marked as confirmed today. Every check keeps this menu honest for the next person.

Got it, thank you.

We'll verify against the restaurant and update this listing as soon as we can. If your note is helpful we'll publish it here so the next person knows too.

Updated August 2026

Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies Menu

Starters & Salads (16)

APPITIZERS

Caprese

Fresh sliced mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, fresh basil and balsamic glaze

$9.31

Chicken tenders

Four hand breaded tenderloins with your choice of dipping sauce

$9.31

Fried Mushrooms

A generous portion with side of ranch

$9.31

Mozzarella Sticks

Six handbreaded sticks, served with marinara sauce

$9.31

Cheese Curds

Enjoy a half pound of crispy cheese cruds paired with sweet chili dip, perfect for sharing (or not!)

$9.31

Jalapeno poppers

Get ready for a flavor explosion! 6 spicy jalapenos lovingly wrapped in a crispy coat and filled to the brim with creamy goodness, paired with a sweet chili sauce that'll make your taste buds dance

$9.31

Cheesy Bread

$9.31

Garlic Knots

$7.21

Fries

$4.51

Loaded Fries

$8.31

Onion Rings

Dive into a heaping pile of our crispy, hand-breaded, golden rings served with a zesty dip that will make your taste buds dance

$9.31

SALADS

Greek salad

Red onion, kalamata olives, green peppers, tomatoes, cucumber, and feta cheese

$12.41

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons

$10.41

Salad Bar (unlimited)

Unlimited trips

$12.43

Antipasto Salad

Salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone cheese, banana peppers, kalamata olives, tomatoes, onions

$12.41

Side Salad

a small salad made by you at our salad bar so you get everything you want and nothing you don't

$5.21

Sandwiches (12)

SUBS

Meatball Sub

8" hoagie piled full with meat, sauce and provolone cheese

$9.31

Chicken bacon ranch Sub

8" hoagie with grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, and our famous ranch dressing

$9.31

Ham & Cheese Melt

$8.31

Chicken Parm Sub

8" hoagie with hand breaded chicken, sauce and provolone cheese

$9.31

ITALIAN SUB

$9.31

CALZONE/STROMBOLI

CALZONE

10" crust hand-stuffed with a blend of ricotta, mozzarella, provolone cheese and 1 topping

$10.95

CALZONE SUPREME

$17.17

CALZONE GODFATHER

Pizza sauce, meatballs, pepperoni, ham, bacon, Italian sausage, mozzarella cheese

$17.17

STROMBOLI

10" crust hand-stuffed with mozzarella, marinara sauce, and 1 topping

$10.95

STROMBOLI SUPREME

$17.17

STROMBOLI GODFATHER

$17.17

STROM-ZONE

The best of both world. Half calzone, half stromboli all baked inside one dough

$10.95

Dinner Specials (9)

DINNERS

Lasagna With Garlic Knots

$18.71

WINGS

6 wings

Jumbo bone-in wings with your choice of sauce

$9.31

12 wings

Jumbo bone-in wings with your choice of sauce

$16.51

20 wings

Jumbo bone-in wings with your choice of sauce

$25.91

60 wings

Jumbo bone-in wings with your choice of sauce

$66.61

9 Boneless Wings

$10.31

15 Boneless Wings

$15.91

20 Boneless Wings

$19.95

Special Of The Month

Chicken Caprese Sub

$9.31

Pizza (65)

PIZZA SLICE SPECIALS

1 slice plain

$4.99

2 slice plain

$9.99

2 Slices +Drink

$12.51

1 slice+ side salad+ Drink

$12.51

2 Slices + Salad +Drink

$14.99

CHEESE PIZZA

12" GLUTEN FREE

$13.95

10" CHEESE PIZZA

Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese

$10.31

14" cheese pizza

Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese

$15.55

18" cheese pizza

Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese

$17.63

SHEET PIZZA

$31.15

24" Cheese Pizza

$24.95

SPECIALTY PIES

10" Meatlovers

$17.25

10" BIANCO

Garlic butter sauce, bacon, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, fresh spinach, garlic parm crust

$14.01

10" GREEK

Pizza sauce, chicken, black olives, green peppers, mozzarella cheese, onion, fetta cheese

$16.17

10" HOT HONEY PIZZA

Pepperoni, bacon, provolone & mozzarella cheese drizzled with our hot honey sauce

$14.01

10" ITALIAN

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, ham, salami, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, onion, provolone cheese

$16.17

10" MARGHERITA

Garlic butter sauce, basil, tomato, mozzarella cheese

$14.01

10" MAUI

Pizza sauce, ham, bacon, pineapple, mozzarella cheese, provolone cheese

$14.01

10" SUPREME

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, ham, black olives, green peppers, mushrooms, Italian sausage, mozzarella cheese, onion

$18.34

14" BIANCO

Garlic butter sauce, bacon, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, fresh spinach, garlic parm crust

$17.25

14" Meatlovers

$22.66

14" GREEK

Pizza sauce, chicken, black olives, green peppers, mozzarella cheese, onion, fetta cheese

$21.58

14" HOT HONEY

Pepperoni, bacon, provolone & mozzarella cheese drizzled with our hot honey sauce

$17.25

14" ITALIAN

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, ham, salami, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, onion, provolone cheese

$21.58

14" MARGHERITA

Garlic butter sauce, basil, tomato, mozzarella cheese

$17.25

14" MAUI

Pizza sauce, ham, bacon, pineapple, mozzarella cheese, provolone cheese

$17.25

14" SUPREME

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, ham, black olives, green peppers, mushrooms, Italian sausage, mozzarella cheese, onion

$21.58

18" BIANCO

Garlic butter sauce, bacon, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, fresh spinach, garlic parm crust

$22.66

18" Meatlovers

$28.07

18" GREEK

Pizza sauce, chicken, black olives, green peppers, mozzarella cheese, onion, fetta cheese

$25.91

18" HOT HONEY

Pepperoni, bacon, provolone & mozzarella cheese drizzled with our hot honey sauce

$22.66

18" ITALIAN

$25.91

18" MARGHERITA

Garlic butter sauce, basil, tomato, mozzarella cheese

$24.51

18" MAUI

$22.66

18" SUPREME

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, ham, black olives, green peppers, mushrooms, Italian sausage, mozzarella cheese, onion

$28.07

SHEET BIANCO

Garlic butter sauce, bacon, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, fresh spinach, garlic parm crust

$43.21

SHEET Meatlovers

$52.95

SHEET GREEK

Pizza sauce, chicken, black olives, green peppers, mozzarella cheese, onion, fetta cheese

$52.95

SHEET HOT HONEY

Pepperoni, bacon, provolone & mozzarella cheese drizzled with our hot honey sauce

$43.21

SHEET ITALIAN

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, ham, salami, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, onion, provolone cheese

$46.46

SHEET MARGHERITA

Garlic butter sauce, basil, tomato, mozzarella cheese

$43.21

SHEET MAUI

Pizza sauce, ham, bacon, pineapple, mozzarella cheese, provolone cheese

$43.21

SHEET SUPREME

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, ham, black olives, green peppers, mushrooms, Italian sausage, mozzarella cheese, onion

$52.95

12" GLUTEN FREE BIANCO

$15.55

12" GLUTENFREE Meatlovers

$18.67

12" GLUTEN FREE GREEK

$17.63

12" GLUTEN FREE HOT HONEY

$15.55

12" GLUTEN FREE ITALIAN

$17.64

12" GLUTEN FREE MARGHERITA

$15.55

12" GLUTEN FREE MAUI

$15.55

12" GLUTEN FREE SUPREME

$19.71

24" BIANCO

$39.47

24" Meatlovers

$47.79

24" GREEK

$47.79

24" HOT HONEY

$39.47

24" ITALIAN

$41.55

24" MARGHERITA

$39.47

24" MAUI

$39.47

24" SUPREME

$47.79

HALF/HALF PIZZA

10" HALF/HALF

$18.34

14" HALF/HALF

$22.66

18" HALF/HALF

$28.07

SHEET HALF/HALF

$52.95

12" Gluten free HALF/HALF

$19.71

24" HALF/HALF

$47.79

Extras (24)

SIDES

Side Ranch

Side of Ranch dressing

$0.98

Side blue Cheese

Side of Blue Cheese Dressing

$0.98

Carrots

$1.07

Celery

$1.07

Chips

$2.89

Onion Rings Side

$6.23

KIDS MENU

Kids tenders (w/fries)

2 tenders with fries and choice of dipping sauce

$8.31

Kids Pizza

8" kids pizza with 1 topping. Up to 2 additional toppings are available

$9.35

Drinks

Sweet Tea

$3.06

Un-Sweet Tea

$3.06

Pepsi (fountain)

$3.06

Pepsi Zero (fountain)

$3.06

Mt Dew (fountain)

$3.06

Lemonade (fountain)

$3.06

Dr Pepper (fountain)

$3.06

Starry (fountain)

$3.06

Water

Glass Wine

$6.44

Bottle Beer

$5.36

Bottle Of Wine

$27.04

20oz bottle soda

$3.06

DESSERT

Cannoli

$5.21

Cheesecake

With topping of your choice (strawberry, raspberry, blueberry)

$9.31

Cinnamon Bread

$7.21

Full Menu

Own this restaurant? Claim it

Own Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies? Claim this listing to add your full menu, prices and hours.

Claim this listing

Photos & Gallery

Own this restaurant? Claim it

Own Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies? Claim this listing to add photos of your space.

Claim this listing

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies have a cocktail or drinks menu?

Yes. Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies lists 13 drinks on this page under Menu. Sweet Tea $3.06, Un-Sweet Tea $3.06, Pepsi (fountain) $3.06.

What food does Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies serve?

Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies publishes Menu, 110 dishes. Dishes start at $0.98.

Does Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies have dessert?

Yes, 3 on the menu. Cannoli $5.21, Cheesecake $9.31, Cinnamon Bread $7.21.

Where is Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies located?

Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies is located at 850 N Jefferson St Unit 910, Monticello, FL 32344.

Is Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies good for groups?

Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies is a pizza restaurant in Monticello. For large groups, we recommend calling ahead at +1 850-997-4000 to check availability.

What type of restaurant is Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies?

Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies is a pizza restaurant located in Monticello, FL.