Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House Menu With Prices

Contact & Location

Bar · $

660 E Alfred Dr, Lake Alfred, FL 33850

(863) 956-5055 · tap to call

garysoysterbar.com

How far is Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House?

660 E Alfred Dr, Lake Alfred, FL 33850

Distance from central Lake Alfred0.6 mi

Straight-line distance from the midpoint of our Lake Alfred listings.

Get Directions

Hours of Operation

MondayClosed

Tuesday4–9 PM

Wednesday4–9 PM

Thursday4–9 PM

Friday4–9 PM

Saturday4–9 PM

Sunday3–8 PM

Happy Hour

Updated August 2026

Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House does not currently offer a confirmed happy hour. The bar features a food menu with prices across 134 verified items, available in full detail below.

Been here recently? Are the menu details still right?

Prices and times change constantly. A quick check keeps this page honest for the next person.

Thanks, what's changed?

Pick anything that's off. We'll update the listing.

What's different

Prices are differentTimes or days changedItems have changedNo longer offeredSomething else

Your note may be published on this page to help other visitors. No name required.

Add a photo of the menu board (optional)

Want to know when it's fixed?

Thanks, that helps.

Marked as confirmed today. Every check keeps this menu honest for the next person.

Got it, thank you.

We'll verify against the restaurant and update this listing as soon as we can. If your note is helpful we'll publish it here so the next person knows too.

Updated August 2026

Oyster Bar & Seafood House Menu

Starters (59)

Oysters

OYSTERS ON HALF SHELL

Raw

Dozen

$24.95

Half Dozen

$12.95

STEAMED OYSTERS

Steamed

Half Bucket

(At Bar Only)

$30.95

Bucket

(At Bar Only)

$54.95

CHAR-GRILLED PARMESAN

Grilled

(8)

$22.95

(12)

$30.95

JALAPENO BACON OYSTERS

Grilled

(8)

$23.95

(12)

$31.95

Appetizers

SHRIMP BOAT

(12 SHRIMP)

$9.95

SHRIMP COCKTAIL

(5 LARGE SHRIMP)

$9.95

CONCH FRITTERS

$11.95

CRAWFISH

(1 LB.) ADD EXTRA SEASONING + 1.00

$12.95

CHEESE STIX

$7.95

FRIED MUSHROOMS

$7.95

FRIED GREEN TOMATOES

$9.95

SMOKED FISH DIP

$9.95

STEAMED JUMBO SHRIMP

(HOT OR COLD)

(12)

$15.95

(6)

$8.95

BUFFALO POPCORN SHRIMP

$9.95

GATOR

$14.95

STONE CRAB CLAWS

(IN SEASON)

MKT PRICE

ONION RINGS

(HOMEMADE)

(HALF)

$5.95

(FULL)

$10.95

STUFFED MUSHROOMS

$11.95

CRAB CAKES

(1)

$9.95

(2)

$17.95

FRIED LOBSTER

(WHEN AVAILABLE)

MKT PRICE

Soups

SEAFOOD GUMBO

CUP

$9.95

BOWL

$13.95

NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER

CUP

$6.95

BOWL

$9.95

Fresh Catch

1 - Pick Your Fish (Or Shellfish)

GROUPER

MARKET PRICE

CATFISH

$19.95

SHRIMP (10)

$20.95

FLOUNDER

$25.95

GATOR

$28.95

SCALLOPS

$29.95

SNAPPER

$25.95

FROG LEGS

$24.95

SHRIMP & SCALLOP COMBO

$26.95

2 - Pick Your Style

FRIED

CAJUN FRIED

GRILLED

BLACKENED (MILD, MED, OR HOT)

BROILED

BROILED & STUFFED WITH OUR HOMEMADE CRAB STUFFING (FISH & SHRIMP ONLY) + 7

3 - Pick Your 2 Sides (Or Salad & Side)

Salad

LARGE CAESAR SALAD

(W/ CHOICE OF CHICKEN OR SHRIMP, ROMAINE LETTUCE, HOMEMADE CAESAR DRESSING, CROUTONS)

$17.95

Sides (12)

GARDEN SALAD

$3.95

COLE SLAW

$3.95

BAKED POTATO

$3.95

NEW POTATOES

$3.95

GARLIC BREAD

$3.95

HASH BROWNS

$3.95

HUSH PUPPIES

$3.95

FRENCH FRIES

$3.95

GRITS

$3.95

W/ CHEESE

$4.50

STEAMED BROCCOLI

$4.95

W/ CHEESE

$5.50

Mains (36)

Steaks

PRIME RIB

(12 OZ, QUEEN CUT)

$28.95

PRIME RIB

(14 OZ, KING CUT)

$31.95

NEW YORK STRIP

(10 OZ)

$23.95

HAMBURGER STEAK

(WITH OR WITHOUT GRILLED ONIONS) SERVED WITH TOSSED SALAD, BAKED POTATO AND GARLIC BREAD

$14.95

Sautéed & Steamed

STEAMED SHRIMP

(½ pound)

$19.95

SNOW CRAB DINNER

(12 OZ)

MARKET PRICE

SHRIMP SCAMPI

$25.95

SAUTEED SCALLOPS

$29.95

CAJUN SHRIMP & SCALLOP PENNE PASTA

$24.95

Surf & Turf

New York Strip Steak with Choice of: Snow Crab Legs or 6 Shrimp

SERVED WITH SALAD, BAKED POTATO AND GARLIC BREAD

$35.95

A-La-Carte

SNOW CRAB

1/2 POUND

MARKET PRICE

SNOW CRAB

1 POUND

MARKET PRICE

KING CRAB

1/2 POUND

MARKET PRICE

KING CRAB

1 POUND

MARKET PRICE

Sandwiches

GROUPER (FRIED)

Fresh Florida Grouper fried to perfection

$17.95

GROUPER (BLACKENED)

Mild, Medium or Hot

$18.95

HOT DOG PLATTER

1/4 lb all beef

$5.95

HAMBURGER PLATTER

1/3 lb all beef on brioche bun, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles (American Cheese + 1)

$9.95

PRIME RIB SANDWICH

W/ GRILLED ONION, MUSHROOMS, & American Cheese

$15.95

Sampler Platters

FRESH WATER COMBO PLATTER

Fried Catfish, Frog Legs, & Gator

$31.95

GARY'S SPECIAL

Fried Seafood Combo Platter Includes catfish, shrimp, scallops, oysters, and clams

$38.95

HOUSE SPECIAL

Fried catfish, shrimp, scallops, oysters, gator tail, and frog legs

$38.95

BROILED SEAFOOD SAMPLER

A luscious variety of snow crab legs, steamed shrimp, gulf flounder & sauteed scallops

$39.95

ALL YOU CAN EAT

Fried Catfish Strips * No Sharing, No To-Go Orders, and No Take Home Boxes

$27.95

Fried Entrees

FRIED SHRIMP

1/2 DOZEN

$15.95

FRIED SHRIMP

DOZEN

$25.95

SWEET AND TENDER FINGERLING CATFISH

SMALL FISH W/ BONES, WHEN AVAILABLE

$18.95

FRIED CATFISH STRIP DINNER

$19.95

FRIED CLAM STRIPS, SWEET & TENDER

$20.95

CRAB CAKE DINNER

$23.95

FRIED OYSTERS (10)

$25.95

FRIED LOBSTER DINNER

(WHEN AVAILABLE)

MARKET PRICE

Junior Mates

CATFISH STRIPS

Served with french fries and hush puppies

$7.95

FRIED GULF FLOUNDER

Served with french fries and hush puppies

$8.95

POPCORN SHRIMP

Served with french fries and hush puppies

$8.95

CHICKEN FINGERS

Served with french fries and hush puppies

$7.95

Desserts (27)

Desserts

KEY LIME PIE

$4.95

"Luther's" PEANUT BUTTER PIE

$6.95

CHEESE CAKE

$4.95

Full Service Bar

PEPSI PRODUCTS

$2.95

ICED TEA

COFFEE

MICHELOB ULTRA

Beer

$3.50

1/2 PITCHER

Beer

$8.95

PITCHER

Beer ASK ABOUT IMPORTS AND FEATURED DRAFTS

$16.95

YUENGLING

Beer

$3.50

PITCHER

Beer

$16.95

CABERNET

Wine

MERLOT

Wine

SANGRIA

Wine

ZINFANDEL

Wine

PINOT GRIGIO

Wine

PINOT NOIR

Wine

SAUVIGNON BLANC

Wine

CHARDONNAY

Wine

GLASS

Wine

$5.95

1/2 CARAFE

Wine

$11.95

CARAFE

Wine

$19.95

RUM RUNNER

Specialty Cocktails Light, Dark & Coconut Rum with tropical flavors and orange juice

GARY'S MARGARITA

Specialty Cocktails Jose Cuervo Gold, triple sec and homemade margarita mix

CADILLAC MARGARITA

Specialty Cocktails Patron Silver, triple sec, splash of OJ, and homemade margarita mix

WATER MOCCASIN

Specialty Cocktails Crown Royal, Peach Schnapps, triple sec, and housemade sour mix

FLORIDA TEA

Specialty Cocktails Jameson Orange, Peach Schnapps, triple sec, and housemade sour mix

Full Menu

Own this bar? Claim it

Own Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House? Claim this listing to add your full menu, prices and hours.

Claim this listing

Photos & Gallery

Own this bar? Claim it

Own Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House? Claim this listing to add photos of your space.

Claim this listing

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House have a cocktail or drinks menu?

Yes. Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House lists 73 drinks on this page under Oyster Bar & Seafood House Menu. Dozen 24.95, Half Dozen 12.95, Half Bucket 30.95.

What food does Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House serve?

Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House publishes Oyster Bar & Seafood House Menu, 58 dishes. Dishes start at 3.95.

Does Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House have dessert?

Yes, 3 on the menu. KEY LIME PIE 4.95, "Luther's" PEANUT BUTTER PIE 6.95, CHEESE CAKE 4.95.

Where is Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House located?

Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House is located at 660 E Alfred Dr, Lake Alfred, FL 33850.

Is Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House good for groups?

Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House is a Bar in Lake Alfred. For large groups, we recommend calling ahead at (863) 956-5055 to check availability.

What type of restaurant is Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House?

Gary's Oyster Bar & Seafood House is a Bar located in Lake Alfred, FL.