Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe Menu With Prices

Name: Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe
Address: 205 Key Deer Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, Big Pine Key, FL, US
Telephone: (305) 872-9912
Price range: $

Contact & Location

coffee shop · $

205 Key Deer Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043

(305) 872-9912 · tap to call

bagelislandcoffee.com

How far is Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe?

205 Key Deer Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043

Distance from central Big Pine Keyin the centre

Straight-line distance from the midpoint of our Big Pine Key listings.

Get Directions

Hours of Operation

MondayClosed

TuesdayClosed

Wednesday7 AM–2 PM

Thursday7 AM–2 PM

Friday7 AM–2 PM

Saturday7 AM–2 PM

Sunday7 AM–1 PM

See It Before You Go

Short videos of Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe from people who went: sandwich, bagel, food, bagels, sandwiches, lunch. Tap to play.

Videos by Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe · Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe · Bagels On The Main · Bagel Master, playing in the creator’s official Instagram player.Not affiliated with DiscoverHappyHours.

Happy Hour

Updated August 2026

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe does not currently offer a confirmed happy hour. The restaurant features a food menu with prices across 69 verified items, available in full detail below.

Been here recently? Are the menu details still right?

Prices and times change constantly. A quick check keeps this page honest for the next person.

Thanks, what's changed?

Pick anything that's off. We'll update the listing.

What's different

Prices are differentTimes or days changedItems have changedNo longer offeredSomething else

Your note may be published on this page to help other visitors. No name required.

Add a photo of the menu board (optional)

Want to know when it's fixed?

Thanks, that helps.

Marked as confirmed today. Every check keeps this menu honest for the next person.

Got it, thank you.

We'll verify against the restaurant and update this listing as soon as we can. If your note is helpful we'll publish it here so the next person knows too.

Updated August 2026

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe Menu

Coffee

Regular / Decaf Coffee

Choose 0% or Whole Milk. Soy Milk add .75 - Ask about our flavored syrups, only .60 more

$1.70/$2.08

Iced Coffee

$1.75/$2.05

Capuccino

$3.50/$3.75

Cafe Con Leche

$3.60/$3.85

Latte

$3.60/$3.85

Espresso

$2.40

Americano

$2.45/$2.55

Hot Teas (Black, Green)

$1.45/$1.70

Chai Latte

$3.55/$3.90

Unsweetened Iced Tea

$1.45/$1.75

Frozen Coffee Coolada

Heath Mocha, Coffee, Vanilla Latte, Mocha, Caramel, Chocolate Mint, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Sugar Free Mocha and Sugar Free Vanilla

$4.65/$4.95

Frozen Non-Coffee Coolada

Cookies & Cream, Green Tea, Vanilla Bean

$5.00/$5.35

Other Beverages

Soy Milk

Add Chocolate Syrup to your Milk - .60

$2.05

YooHoo

Add Chocolate Syrup + .60

$1.35

Bottled Water

$1.50

Can Soda

$1.25

Juices, Snapple, Vitamin Water

$2.00

Hot Breakfast

All American Breakfast

Eggs, Hashbrowns & Toast

$4.75/$6.55/$7.50

Atkins

3 Eggs, Choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage plus a slice of Cheese and Tomato

$8.25

3 Egg Omelets

Choose from two items below - served with Toast (Cheese, Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Onion, Tomato or Roasted Red Pepper)

$7.95

Belgian Waffle

$4.75

French Toast

$3.35/$4.75/$5.50

Side Items

Toast with Butter

$1.95

Hashbrown

$1.85

Oatmeal or Grits

$3.35

Bacon, Ham or Sausage

$2.75

Egg

$2.00

Pastries and Desserts

Muffins

$3.00

Butter Croissant

$3.00

Chocolate Croissant

$3.00

Cinnamon Bun

$3.00

Freshly Baked Cookie

$1.50

Milkshakes

Smoothies

Mango, Banana, Pina Colada, Strawberry-Banana, Mixed Berry

$4.65/$4.95

Chocolate or Vanilla

$5.35/$5.65

Turbo Milkshake

6oz Espresso Shot Added

$5.25

Bagels Made Fresh Daily

Single

Bagel Options: Plain, Egg, Blueberry, Sesame, Onion, Salt, Asiago, Poppy, Garlic, Everything, Pumpernickel, Multi-grain, Whole Wheat, Cinnamon/Raisin Cream Cheese Options: Plain, Low-Fat, Nova-Lox, Artichoke-Garlic-Olive, Scallion, Walnut-Raisin, Jalapeno, Strawberry, Vegetable, Roasted Red Pepper (4oz, 8oz & 16oz To-Go Containers Available)

$1.25

Half-Dozen

Call a day in advanced for a discount!

$7.50

One Dozen

Call a day in advanced for a discount!

$15.00

Bagel With

Butter

$1.95

Butter & Jelly or Honey

$2.35

Plain Cream Cheese

$2.85

Flavored Cream Cheese

$3.45

PB & J

$2.45

Nova Lox Spread

$4.60

Bagel or Breakfast Sandwich

One Egg

Add Lettuce, Tomato, or Onion for just .25 each

$2.65

Egg and Cheese

$3.45

Egg and Meat

Bacon, Ham, or Sausage

$4.75

Egg, Cheese and Meat

Bacon, Ham, or Sausage

$5.50

Sandwiches

Grilled Cheese

American, Swiss, Provolone, or Cheddar. Add Bacon and Tomato for only 3.50 more! Extra Meat - 1.50 | Extra Cheese - .50 | Extra Lettuce, Tomato, Onion - .25 Each

$4.25

Lox

Bagel with Onion, Tomato, Capers and Cream Cheese

$9.50

BLT

Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo

$5.25

Grilled Reuben

Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese, and Thousand Island

$9.65

Bella Dawna Panini

Plain Bagel with Fresh Mozzarella, Salami, Roasted Red Pepper Basil and Aged Balsamic Glaze

$7.35

Cuban

Pork, Ham, Salami, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle, Mayo, Deli Mustard, pressed

$9.95

NY Club

Turkey, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Bacon and Mayo on Two Pieces of Toast

$8.75

Italian 6

Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Banana Peppers and Italian Dressing

$9.95

Roast Beef Bomber

Grilled Croissant with Roast Beef, Veggie Cream Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion

$10.50

Manatee Munchie

Choice of Bagel, Tomato, Lettuce and Veggie Cream Cheese

$4.25

Hamburger

$8.00

Cheeseburger

$8.75

Pulled Pork

$6.50

Made to Order Sandwiches

From top to bottom just the way you want

MEAT: Ham, Turkey, Salami, Roast Beef (+2.50), Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad TOPPINGS:(Choose Any Three) Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles, Red Onion, Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Roasted Red Peppers, Mayo, Ketchup, Deli Mustard, Yellow Mustard, Oil & Vinegar CHEESE:(+1.00) American, Swiss, Cheddar, Provolone BREAD: White, Wheat, Rye. 6" Cuban Sub-Roll or Croissant - add Cheese 1.00

$6.96

Salads

Chef Salad

Ham, Turkey, Choice of 2 Cheeses (American, Swiss, Cheddar, Provolone). Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Cucumber and Roasted Red Peppers Dressings: Thousand-Island, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Italian, Balsamic-Vinaigrette, Oil & Vinegar

$8.75

Cobb Salad

Turkey, Bacon, Egg, Tomato, Red Onion, Cucumber, Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce with Blue Cheese Dressing

$7.95

Garden Salad

Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Cucumber and Your Choice of Cheese * Add a scoop of Chicken or Tuna Salad - 2.90

$4.75

Small Salad

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion

$2.70

Extras

Assorted Chips